Quick Links

“Observation Status” Policy Moving Through Court System

Posted on: 11/28/2017

The hospital administration policy fight over “Observation Status” versus “Inpatient Status” may finally hit a boiling point this year. In July, the United States District Court of Connecticut ruled in favor of Medicare beneficiaries seeking administrative review of their “observation status.” In Alexander v. Price, 3:11-CV-1703, U.S. District Court Judge Michael Shea certified a class of individuals who are now eligible to sue the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services for the right to challenge the arbitrary label. Those eligible to join the suit against the Department are all Medicare beneficiaries who, on or after January 1, 2009: (1) have received or will have received “observation services” as an outpatient during a hospitalization; and (2) have received or will have received an initial determination that the observation services are covered (or subject to coverage) under Medicare Part B are eligible to join the class-action suit.

According to documentation filed in the case, the number of class members may well reach into the hundreds of thousands. The court cited a Brown University study originally published in 2012 that identified over 900,000 Medicare beneficiaries who experienced “observation status” hospital stays in 2009. The plaintiffs in the case argued that classification under “observation status” rather than “inpatient status” results in higher out-of-pocket costs during and after hospital stays. During the hospital stay, patients under “observation status” face higher costs for drugs and copayments for hospital services. After the hospital stay, patients could face astronomical expenses for skilled nursing facility care.

Click here to read the court decision.

Click here to visit the Center for Medicare Advocacy, the lead organization in representing the plaintiffs.

Return to Legislative Postings

SAVE THE DATE | ACMA 2025 National Conference

Join us for ACMA 2025 National Conference, April 3-6, 2025 in Denver, CO. Don't miss out on the premier case management and transitions of care conference of the year!
Experience ACMA at National!

Save The Date | 2024 Leadership and Physician Advisor Conference

Our 2024 Leadership and Physician Advisor Conference is November 18-20 in Huntington Beach, CA! Health plans and providers, this conference has everything you need.
Find out more here!

Share Your Research | Collaborative Case Management

Do you have a project or measurable initiative you've instituted at your organization? Have you conducted research on a current issue in the field? Share your experiences and results with your professional community! Email your proposal or questions: vmatthews@acmaweb.org.
Learn More!

Get ACMA News in the Palm of Your Hand

Join the conversation with ACMA! Text the keyword ACMA to 844-554-2497 to stay up to date on all the latest news and announcements, delivered straight to your phone!

Now Accepting Presentations for Chapter Conferences

We are now accepting presentations for upcoming ACMA chapter conferences. If you have a unique solution, intervention or strategy to improve case management, this is a great opportunity to share your knowledge and be a part of ACMA's national-caliber education at the local level. There is no deadline to submit; presentations will be accepted throughout the year so you can prepare a submission as your schedule allows.
Submit a presentation!

SAVE THESE DATES | National Case Management Week

2024 - October 13-19
2025 - October 12-18
2026 - October 11-17
2027 - October 10-16
2028 - October 8-14